Live Green and Earn Points


Because You Asked

Is Mulching Really the Best Option for Old Christmas Trees?

By Recyclebank |

From rebuilding dunes to creating backyard wildlife spaces, there’s a lot you can do with fallen trees — but mulching is still tops.


Dear Recyclebank: I realize that some municipalities turn logs, slash, and post-holiday trees into mulch, but aren’t there more practical ways to reincarnate that wood (like donating it to paper making factories or companies that create bedding for animals)? –Elizah L., Denver, CO


Dear Elizah: We think mulch is a fantastic solution that diverts yard waste out of the landfill, but appreciate that there are trade-offs to every method of reuse and recycling, including this one. The energy calculation for municipal mulch operations depends on how far town vehicles are driving the waste around (or all of those private vehicles burning fuel driving to a central drop-off point) and what type of mulching equipment is used. Despite that carbon cost, mulch is a valuable end product: Mulch keeps moisture in the soil between rainstorms and waterings, and helps with weed control, reducing or eliminating pesticide use. If your town has a special tree pick-up service — most do after the holidays — we recommend taking advantage of it.


In some coastal areas, an alternative use for old Christmas trees and logs is to rebuild dunes impacted by beach erosion and major storms. Our members in Brazoria, TX, might be familiar with the town’s Dunes Day event, which gets residents excited to help protect their shores, and New York and New Jersey coastlines benefited from recycled Christmas trees after Hurricane Sandy, as well.


Great idea on pet bedding as another approach to using old wood. Some pet shelters and horse stables may accept wood shavings, but you'll want to call to see their specifications before you start shredding. They may consider it easier and safer to purchase shavings from a company that sources pesticide-free wood, kiln-dries it, and sifts out dust prior to packing.


Members who use the Internet should check out their local Craigslist and FreeCycle sites and use those online resources to announce available free wood whenever they have firewood, logs, or other yard waste that someone might be able to use. Maybe there's a wood artist, terrarium enthusiast, Pinterest crafter, weekend warrior, floral designer, or boat builder who would love to turn your trash into treasure.


Rotting the wood yourself is an option if you have a yard, aren't restricted by association rules or in an area prone to wild fires, and if it won't annoy your neighbors. You might even be able to create a “snag”: Consider leaving a small corner of your backyard a wildlife habitat welcoming to insects and small mammals by starting with rotting wood.


Finally, we love it when diverting material from the waste stream can provide an opportunity for fun, too. Reach out to local pre-schools and daycares when you have logs to share, in case they have some natural elements in their play spaces. We’ve also found that, like empty cardboard boxes, many children love the simple pleasure of rolling small logs around and rearranging them.


The New York Times



How do you dispose of trees (Christmas or otherwise)? Share your best ideas and advice with us in the comments below!

Share with Your Friends & Family
  • Felix I. 1 year ago
    Which one is better, a real or a fake Christmas tree, and why?
  • June S. 2 years ago
    Our area has several drop off places for Christmas trees. Since we are on the coast, most of them get used to help rebuild dunes.
  • Dee R. 3 years ago
    We would take quite a few of the Christmas trees and take them to the lake and sink them. They provide a home for the fish; then you know where to go fishing in the future for sure catches.
  • Doris W. 4 years ago
    Dating to way, way back in 1960, my dad ALWAYS bought our Christmas trees from the local nursery, and planted them after the holidays... he was the ORIGINAL "recycler"... today, since I don't have my dad's green thumb, I have an artificial tree that I've been using since the 1980's.
    • Doris W. 4 years ago
      To this day, I can't understand why ANYONE would buy a dead tree for Christmas!!!!!! If you don't have a yard to plant it in, just buy a very lifelike fake tree that you can use year after year!
    • Doris W. 4 years ago
      ... and, if you're totally into the "pine scent" of the season, you can either cut a few boughs off a pine tree for decorations (leaving the tree unharmed) or go to your local store and buy some pine-scented air freshener...
  • Laura L. 4 years ago
    I think the good thing about using the yard waste and christmas trees for mulch is that it replaces the need for turning virgin trees into mulch. But I have seen friends cut the tree trunks into chunks about 18-24 inches high and use them for stools or tables around a fire pit outside or just anywhere in the back yard, it's great for kids to sit and play on.
  • View More